California Criminal Defense Lawyers

California Criminal & DUI Defense Lawyers

Free Initial Consultation

(800) 944-8912

  • Home
  • California Criminal Charges
  • California Criminal Sentencing
  • About Us
    • Disclaimer / Privacy Policy
  • Blog

When Oakland Cops Shoot, Their Own Investigate

April 29, 2013

When a police officer fires his weapon upon a civilian, they have to have pretty significant justification. As a matter of fact, according to the U.S. Supreme Court, they have to be acting in reasonable self defense or in the defense of another. But, when an officer in Oakland shoots a civilian, the public isn’t convinced this standard is being met, and understandably so considering they are being investigated by one of their own.

EBRP police car 1 8-22-09In an in-depth Bay Citizen article, we can see how using a police officer or even former police officer for the investigation of a police shooting could create some serious doubts in the minds of the public and some serious conflicts of interest.

When the police shoot a civilian, two investigations occur. One investigation is done at a departmental level to determine if the officer broke police policy in the shooting. The other is done to determine if a the shooting amounted to a criminal act. Who conducts this second investigation depends on the county in question.

Across California, practices vary. In Oakland and other locales, the District Attorney typically employs a cop or former cop as an investigator. While a detective or police officer may have the legal know-how to conduct an investigation, they come with a suspected allegiance to the silent code of brotherhood among officers. In other words, they are difficult to trust for an unbiased opinion on the matter.

Prosecutors say using a police officer doesn’t necessarily “bias the investigation or outcome of a case,” according to the Bay Citizen. But it certainly doesn’t do anything for public relations either.

“Even though he might not want to be a policeman again, he still has an allegiance to the brotherhood,” said law professor Charles Wolfram from Cornell University. “If they’re from the same department, that could create obvious problems.”

“It undermines the legitimacy of the investigation. At the very least, they should try to find investigators hired by somebody else,” says Stanford Law School professor Deborah Rhode.

When a former police officer is used to investigate the actions of a current officer, the public is left feeling like the “other guy” in a we vs. them scenario. Regardless of that investigator’s skills, it is difficult to trust them with such a heavy responsibility.

Though it truly isn’t “us vs. them” in most scenarios, it can feel that way when you are the one under arrest. You deserve fair treatment and under the current climate within many police departments, it’s easy to feel like you are targeted regardless of your rights or the truth about an incident.

If you are arrested and charged with a criminal offense, whether it’s a drug crime or robbery, we may be able to help. Contact our offices today to discuss your case.

Filed Under: criminal law Tagged With: criminal justice, police

Free Consultation

Contact our attorneys for a free legal case evaluation on any criminal charge by calling:


(800) 944-8912
Receive our free legal defense consultation and case evaluation. We'll explain what you are facing in plain language, and tell you how we can help.















By checking this box and clicking "Submit", you agree the phone number you provided above may be used to contact you (including autodialed, pre-recorded calls, artificial voice calls and/or SMS text). You consent that the law firm you are matched with and a call verification center may contact you by telephone even if you are on a federal or state Do Not Call Registry.

DUI Charges

  • DUI Laws – 1st Offense
  • DUI 2nd Offense
  • Wet Reckless
  • Ignition Interlock Devices

Criminal Charges

  • Assault & Battery
  • Burglary
  • Disorderly Conduct
  • Domestic Assault & Domestic Violence
  • Drug Possession
    • Drug Possession Intent To Sell
    • Cocaine Possession
    • Marijuana Possession
    • Heroin Possession
    • Methamphetamine Possession
  • Driving While License Suspended
  • Embezzlement
  • Failure to Appear in Court
  • False Imprisonment / Kidnapping
  • Firearms / Weapons Charges
  • Forgery & Embezzlement
  • Indecent Exposure
  • Leaving the Scene of an Accident/Hit & Run
  • Prostitution
  • Reckless Driving
  • Restraining Order Violation
  • Robbery
  • Sex Crimes
  • Stalking
  • Threatening
  • Theft/Shoplifting
  • Vandalism & Arson
Copyright © 2019 Get Lawyer Leads, Inc.
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. This is not a law firm or referral service and does not provide legal advice. This is a free matching service only, claim reviews will be performed by a third party attorney. An attorney-client relationship is not formed when you submit the form and you are under no obligation to retain a lawyer who contacts you through this service. Services are not available in all states.